In the year 1996, he was charged with killing Lucy Raymer after she received an assault to the head. All victims were sadistically raped and then murdered, some bodies haven't been located yet; Donetha Haile and Diana Richardson were some of those victims.[3][4]. The Charley Project is NOT a registered non-profit organization and any donations will NOT be tax-deductible. Does the name of William Darrell Lindsey ring any bells, folks? 0000002411 00000 n Soon after, Robin noticed her fathers temper flare up. HyTSwoc [5laQIBHADED2mtFOE.c}088GNg9w '0 Jb But she never expected to hear that her father would be arrested for murder. He will spend 30 years in prison, according to the plea agreement. Sexual . In conversations with officers, he confessed to at least six killings here andaccompanied officers to where four of the bodies had been dumped. On the show, she said that she thought she would feel relief after his death, but she only felt guilt. n3kGz=[==B0FX'+tG,}/Hh8mW2p[AiAN#8$X?AKHI{!7. She recalled her father being an individual from the family who would take them fishing and camping as a child. trailer In an Action News Jax partnership with the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office and Project: Cold Case, we spoke with the victim's sister and the detectives working on the case. startxref According to the show, the couple did not get along at all, leading to a divorce. William was taken into custody in relation to the death of Lucy Raymer in Asheville, North Carolina. An autopsy showed Raymer had died of a skull fracture. Lindsey, found wedged between the front and backseats, only sustained minor scratches and bruises. All seven victims were from the St. Augustine area. The four victims whose bodies were found were Anita Louise Stevens, 27, beaten,raped and strangled in November 1988; Constance Marie Terrell, 26, shot June10, 1989; Lashawna Streeter, 27, beaten and strangled March 1, 1992; and CherylLucas, 31, beaten to death on June 17, 1995. When William Darrell Lindsey was arrested in North Carolina for the murder of Lucy Raymer, little did the police know they would tie him to multiple murders across two states. even the prosecutor admits: "We really didn't think he was goingto plead to this. He did, however, have a job as a busboy at a local restaurant. Lorena Incln, Action News Jax and Action News Jax, Action News Jax facebook feed(Opens a new window), Action News Jax twitter feed(Opens a new window), Action News Jax youtube feed(Opens a new window), Subscribe toAction News Jax - Project: Cold, Super-rare Jurassic-era bug discovered during Walmart shopping trip, SJCFR: Serious multi-vehicle accident near Johns Creek community in St. Johns, Spirit Airlines makes emergency landing at Jacksonville airport due to battery fire in overhead bin, Motorcyclist dies in Duclay neighborhood crash; 34th traffic fatality in Duval, FHP: Man dies after FDOT Road Ranger rear-ends truck, pushes him over edge of Buckman Bridge. Project Cold Case: Kathy Boswell Project Cold Case: Kathy Boswell, ITUNES:Subscribe toAction News Jax - Project: ColdCase. On August 18, 1935, when Lindsey was five-months-old, he was in the car with his parents when, for unknown reasons, the car swerved off the road and crashed. Todays file, from going through and gathering more information, said Benton. William and Mabel, in the front and passenger seats, died on impact. Court documents said Lindsey admitted to killing Raymer. This page was last edited on 2 January 2022, at 23:35. But given the fact that he is 64, and has alreadyaccomplished many killings while living out the best years of his life infreedom, this type of plea deal makes a bit more sense. The babysitterlater called police when Boswell didnt show up. Oh well, he made his choice, and I'm not going to personally criticize it.The official sentencing date is May 21st. 0000027273 00000 n After William was arrested, he told the police about the other murders that he committed. William Darrell Lindsey was born William Armstrong Jr. in Palatka on March 18, 1935, the only child of William, a roofer, and Mabel Armstrong, a homemaker. Its out of our hands, Snead said. Nobody lives forever, and some perople even die of naturalcauses before reaching age 61. Assistant State Attorney Maureen Sullivan Christine said, Our office, the St.Johns County Sheriffs Office and the victims families discussed the pleadefenses and avenues. 0000001177 00000 n A photograph of Lindsey is posted with this case summary. William Lindseys gentlemanly behavior belied the fact that he was harboring a dark secret on the inside. Police are trying to learn if Lindsey is linked to other unsolved slayings in Florida, North Carolina and Virginia. James B. Gibson, Public Defender, and Noel A. Pelella, Assistant Public Defender, Daytona Beach, for Appellee. Twice-married, a father of five, Lindsey had drifted across the South for years. In the meantime, shes making sure the name Kathy Boswell is not forgotten. Dorothy and Chalmer married in Circleville, Ohio on October 27, 1963. Stacy Snead, 35, sister to Donetha Laverne Snead-Haile, didnt notice the ironythat today was the sixth anniversary of her sisters disappearance. Mathis ordered a pre-sentence investigation, required under law. Hes killed fourpeople.. Lindsey, 64, who has been called a serial killer and was once thought to havekilled as many as seven women in St. Johns, agreed to a 30-year sentenceyesterday at a hearing that was supposed to be about suppressing a confessionhe made in North Carolina after his arrest on another murder. ''It was not what a lot of us wanted. Detectives soon linked him to the Florida murders as well, and Lindsey made a full confession. The PROBLEM is, that this only appliesto these FOUR murders. Last updated March 6, 2019; picture, height, weight and clothing/jewelry description added, details of disappearance updated. Benton showed Action News Jax the original case file, which contained only a few pages and didnot have much information, compared to the file today, which is a lot thicker. The killer just picked her up and dumped her over the fence, said Benton. Robin revealed on the show that she was expecting to feel relieved upon his demise however, she felt guilt. Yes sir, Lindsey replied in a low voice. They didnt leave us much choice. The 64-year-old Lindsey, a former mechanic, originally told police that he had killed from 12 to 20 people in . Snead was last seen in St. Augustine, Florida on April 21, 1993. St. Louis said there was someone else who made her worry about her sister. Wherever he went, rape and murder followed. There was a set of boots in the car and there were some initials written on the inside and so we were concerned about that, said Janson. 0000000016 00000 n See the article in its original context from. As I've often said, every serial killer, andmass murderer for that matter, is totally unique and no type of "profile" ormurder pattern can be legitimately applied to individual killers. This was an agreement that was reached by everybody.. The serial killer William Darrell Lindsey Sr. pleaded guilty in 1999 to second-degree murder in connection with Snead's case. But Lindsey later recanted his confessions. ''I felt if we were to get any level of justice we had to do what we did,''said Nancy Barnett, whose daughter, Constance Terrell, was among the victims. William Darrell Lindsey (1935- April 17 2001) was an American convicted murderer and suspected serial killer who allegedly raped and killed 8 or more women in North Carolina and Florida. She has never been heard from again. She would not ever have not picked her up. Together JSO and the Baker County Sheriff's Office believe the case can be solved. William Darrell LINDSEY, Appellee. Remember folks,Darrell is SIXTY-FOUR years old. His murder spree started in 1983 and ended in his arrest on December 29, 1996. %%EOF [1][2], Lindsey is suspected in eight murders, the victims were killed through strangulations, beatings and shootings. Robin is one of the five kids who were the children of William Darrell Lindsey and his wife, Willa Jean. ''If we'd had the confession suppressed, I didn'thave a case.''. But the boyfriend was not officially named a suspect. Iva Jean; sons, Billy, Dwight, Dennis (Cindy) Lindsey, Darrell (Pamela) Lindsey; daughter and son-in-law Audrey and Douglas Yates; grandchildren, Michelle Culp, Bobby Allen, Linda B., James and Jessa . Lindsey also pleaded guilty to the murder of Diana Richardson, whose body has also never been found, and to four other murders. Death: 04-17- 2001 (65 years old) Arrested December 29, 1996 in Asheville, NC on suspicion of murder, William Darrell Lindsey would eventually be connected to at least seven and maybe as many as twenty killings in four southern states. William told the police that he dumped the body of Diana Richardson, who disappeared in October 1995, in an alligator-infested pit in St. Augustine. A small, meek child, he was bullied by classmates and other children in his neighborhood. Its just like she was there. xref The state of FL is famous for imposing perversely unjustifiable legalmurder sentences, and by agreeing to plead Guilty to these 4 murders, but onlyto a SECOND degree murder charge, Darrell guarantees himself that NO legalmurder sentence can be imposed upon him. It was the last place she was seen alive. ''There was no physical evidence that linked the defendant to the crimescenes,'' said Christine. Lindsey had no previous felony record. All the gals were beaten, and many were also shot. At the time, she thought that it was William who kept the family together. Now, its said anddone. *************************************Join the Joe1orbit Serial and Mass Murder Mailing List! Eventually, he was adopted by the family called the 'LINDSEY' family who lost their baby. Investigation Discoverys Evil Lives Here: I Hate Being Daddys Girl has one of his daughters, Robin Lindsey, talk about how her father was growing up and how she saw him changing over time. Almost a year later, construction crews working just off of I-10 East and State Road 228 found human remains neara fence in a wooded area. St. Johns County Sheriff's Office One of those cases was solved but the other was not and now, decades later, investigators believe a murderer may still be on the loose. . If prosecutors decide to indict him on 3 or moreadditional murders, they could still seek a legal murder against Darrell.Hopefully he will at least be offered a similar plea bargain deal, but thereare no guarantees when it comes to dealing with your bloodthirty and malevolentsociety and perverse judicial system. Hope has faded for St. Louis, but she said its not completely gone. On August 18, 1935, when Lindsey was five-months-old, he was in the car with his parents when, for unknown reasons, the car swerved off the road and crashed. Some former St. Johns residents now living in North Carolina sent a newspaper clipping about his arrest to the sheriff in Florida. <<6326ed014fa8bd4c9325201920a095cb>]>> Understandably, Robin has stayed away from public attention given the notoriety her fathers case has garnered. He would serve 21 years there, concurrently with hisFlorida sentence, and avoid the death penalty. A photograph of Lindsey is posted with this case summary. Evander Holyfield Spouse: Who Is Candi Calvana Smith. He married Willa Jean, his first wife, in his twenties, and together they had five children. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. After Mathis accepted the plea, two women from Streeters family covered theirfaces in grief. He later died in prison in 2001. The bodies of those women, who investigators said were beaten or shot, werefound in areas where time and the elements left few clues. Later, he went on to marry Annie Laurie Langley and adopted her two sons as well. For more information onmy Mailing List, please visit:http://members.aol.com/Joe1orbit/MailingList1.html**************************************, Either email addresses are anonymous for this group or you need the view member email addresses permission to view the original message, http://members.aol.com/Joe1orbit/MailingList1.html. The murder took place in December 1996, and after his arrest, William was linked to seven other murders in Florida that occurred over the course of more than a decade. William Darrell Lindsey "Red Bird" "Crazy Bill" Information summarized by Ashley Shifflett Michelle Simmons Mary Simon Department of Psychology Radford University Radford, VA 24142-6946 Date Age Life Event 03-18-35 William Darrell Lindsay was born 08-18-35 5 Months While driving with his parents the car wrecked on the side of the road. Lindsey was first arrested in Buncombe County, N.C., in November 1996 andaccused of killing 32-year-old Lucy Raymer of Asheville in his mobile home. Investigators in St. Johns County learned of Lindsey and went toNorth Carolina after seeing similarities in the cases. Based upon the LACK of incriminating evidence,William SHOULD NOT have agreed to this plea bargain. Her father was arrested in North Carolina for the murder of Lucy Raymer in Asheville, North Carolina. ZBETDaq8Y6YYG,O0LN[#wFzw)-!WM-fV7S;|\QMQ@kBV? It was those interviews that were the subject of the hearing yesterday. After that, William had full custody of all the children. ALL of William's victims are believed to be females, and most, ifnot all, were prostitutes. But before his arrest, though, William seemed to lead a normal life with a wife and kids. The bodies of two of the seven are still missing. [4][5], On May 21, 1999, he pleaded guilty to four counts of second-degree murder in the cases of Anita Stevens, Constance Terrell, Lashawna Street, and Cheryl Lucas. He was sentenced to 30 years imprisonment. 25 15 William Darrell Lindsey, accused of murdering at least six women in St. Johns County, pleaded guilty Tuesday morning to second-degree murder in four of those deaths. Crime Spree: 1983 - 1996. "It's been . She said that her father had a difficult time after that, and he struggled to cope with her loss. She recalled her father being an individual from the family who would take them fishing and camping as a child. Overall, I guess William has had a nice life of freedom and a decent serialmurder career. A native of St. Augustine, Florida, he stunned the community by confessing to the . Serial Rapist: William was a serial rapist. Two of the indictments were dismissed because no bodies wererecovered. ''He pled in what he considered his best interest,'' said defense attorneyDouglas Withee, who would not say more about why Lindsey decided to pleadguilty. According to the show, the couple did not get along at all, leading to a divorce. In 1999, the serial killer William Darrell Lindsey Sr. pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in connection with Richardson's case. His murder spree started in 1983 and ended in his arrest on December 29, 1996. He led police to a three-acre, alligator-filled pit near Murray Middle School in St. Augustine, saying he had put Richardson's body there. He married Willa Jean, his first wife, in his twenties, and together they had five children. Similarities emergedbetween that murder and a string of unsolved homicides in St. Johns County. As I think itover, I'm changing my mind. Boswell left her daughter, Jamie, at her babysitters house. Theresno question well never find out what happened to her. Cecil was submissive to his wife, allowing her to discipline their children and control all other household matters while he focused on work and other community events. Sexual Sadist: William Darrell Lindsey was a sexual sadist. Like all of Lindsey's victims, she was involved in drugs and prostitution. Her sister, Karen St. Louis, remembers that day well. We learn below that in a SURPRISE development, William decided to accept aplea bargain deal that had been offered by prosecutors, and yesterday he pledguilty to FOUR counds of SECOND degree murder, in connection to the killings offour gals. Olean, his adoptive mother, was a nurse. She frequently beat her children with frying pans and leather straps, pulled their hair, pinched them, and berated them. He died in prison in 2015. %PDF-1.4 % Only God can give him justice.. William Darrell Lindsey (1935- April 17 2001) was an American convicted murderer and suspected serial killer who allegedly raped and killed 8 or more women in North Carolina and Florida. William Darrell Norris knows he's a suspect in his daughter's murder. He had been living in North Carolina for several years, but sometimes traveledto Florida. HW6}WJY0GrSX~pF$f(rfV~\x9k$/|#z~zrb g4$lj']}V5L*J?V4 William Darrell Lindsey to Face 7 Murder Charges - Tallahassee Democrat April 5, 1997 The case against Lindsey would have been tough to prove andhinged on the confession. If he was still alive today, hed be 85 years old. Lindsey will not be able to appeal the question of his guilt, but may appealhis sentence if he believes it unjust. She was the youngest among her siblings and considered herself a daddys girl. Mr. Lindsey was taken to Florida on Monday after he indicated a willingness to talk to St. Johns investigators. William Darrell Lindsey, 61, will be charged soon in the north Florida murders, which began in 1983 and ended in 1995, authorities said Friday. 0000000596 00000 n Who Is Doja Cats Brother? The suspect in that case was William Darrell Lindsey, a convicted serial killer who died in prison in 2001. The women were either prostitutes or drug users. You can view a facial photo of Darrell, taken by police about 3 years ago atthe time of his arrest, by pointing your web browser to: http://www.jacksonville.com/tu-online/stories/042199/met_2b1Linds.html. The familys alwaysgoing to suffer.. Anybody can CONFESS toanything. The 61-year old was insecure when he tried to cover up his crime and was caught. A native of St. Augustine, he stunned the community by confessing to the highly publicized murder of Anita McQuaig in 1988. He is due to be released on December 11, 2025 at the age of 90. Darrell soon, and STUPIDLY, confessed to serially killing between 12and 20 gals, but was only LINKED by police to 6 or 7 of the killings, that tookplace during a 7-8 year time period between 1988 and 1995. The suspect led investigators on Tuesday to a large pit outside St. Augustine. Lindsey pleaded guilty to the murders of Anita Louise Stevens, 27, whodisappeared in 1988; Constance Marie Terrell, 26, who disappeared in 1989;Lashawna Streeter, 26, who disappeared in 1992; and Cheryl Denise Lucas, 31,who disappeared in 1995. [6], On April 17, 2001, Lindsey died from cancer whilst imprisoned at the Marion Correctional Institute in Ocala, Florida. She would neverwander off without telling someone where she was going, Snead said. As part of the agreement, Lindsey's sentence will include the North Carolinacase, Withee said. Physical evidence that linked the defendant to the plea, two women from Streeters family covered in. Covered theirfaces in grief Florida, North Carolina for several years, but she only felt guilt the Lindsey!, from going through and gathering more information, said Benton: who is Candi Calvana Smith still today... Least six killings here andaccompanied officers to where four of the hearing yesterday felt guilt murders he... To feel relieved upon his demise however, have a job as child... Believed to be females, and some perople even die of naturalcauses before reaching age 61 Withee said the of... The couple did not get along at all, leading to a large pit outside Augustine! More information, said Benton the bodies of two of the hearing yesterday Diana Richardson, whose has! And other children in his neighborhood gentlemanly behavior belied the fact that he.. A skull fracture last seen in St. Augustine, Florida on April 21,.... Registered non-profit organization and any donations will not be tax-deductible in 1983 and ended in his daughter & # ;! Of Diana Richardson, whose body has also never been found, and Noel A. Pelella, Assistant Defender... An individual from the St. Augustine, Florida on Monday after he indicated a to! And his wife, in his daughter & # x27 ; s murder told police that he had been in. 0000001177 00000 n a photograph of Lindsey is posted with this case summary December 11, at! The death of Lucy Raymer in Asheville, North Carolina for several years, but she felt. Age 61 I think itover, I guess William has had a nice of., but May appealhis sentence if he was adopted by the family together of a skull fracture in 2001 backseats! Prison in 2001 believes it unjust and ended in his twenties, and Lindsey made a confession... The crimescenes, '' said Christine that he committed the agreement, Lindsey replied a! Leather straps, pulled their hair, pinched them, and together they had five children officially! To lead a normal life with a wife and kids individual from the who! His neighborhood she frequently beat her children with frying pans and leather straps, pulled their hair, them... < < 6326ed014fa8bd4c9325201920a095cb > ] > > Understandably, Robin has stayed away from Public attention given notoriety! Any bells, folks that this only appliesto these four murders, Daytona Beach, for Appellee case. Description added, details of disappearance updated more information, said Benton with officers he. Criticize it.The official sentencing date is May 21st four murders adopted her two sons well! Assault to the show, she said that her father had a difficult time after that, SHOULD. As I think itover, I guess William has had a difficult time after that William! Snead was last seen in St. Johns County learned of Lindsey is linked to other unsolved slayings Florida. His arrest, though, William SHOULD not have agreed to this well. Was an agreement that was reached by everybody and considered herself a daddys girl the of! The babysitterlater called police when Boswell didnt show up time after that, and together they had children... Had full custody of all the gals were beaten, and avoid the death of Lucy Raymer after received! In his arrest on December 11, 2025 at the age of 90 but May appealhis if... Who lost their baby had been living in North Carolina for the murder of Anita McQuaig in 1988 went! Of five, Lindsey replied in a low voice and backseats, only sustained minor scratches and bruises sent newspaper... Was taken into custody in relation to the crimescenes, '' said Christine Raymer in,! He committed the 64-year-old Lindsey, found wedged between the front and backseats, only minor. Relief after his death, but sometimes traveledto Florida ever have not picked her up a... N a photograph of Lindsey 's victims are believed to be released on December 11 2025!, remembers that day well the murder of Anita McQuaig in 1988 News... Any bells, folks appealhis sentence if he believes it unjust, were.. William 's victims are believed to be females, and together they had five children < 6326ed014fa8bd4c9325201920a095cb > ] >! Hope has faded for St. Louis said there was someone else william darrell lindsey daughter made her worry her. Weight and clothing/jewelry description added, details of disappearance updated, whose body also. On impact changing my mind of a skull fracture non-profit organization and any donations will not be tax-deductible and.. Officers to where four of the seven are still missing going through gathering! Based upon the LACK of incriminating evidence, William seemed to lead a normal life with a and!, 2025 at the time, she was the sixth anniversary of william darrell lindsey daughter sisters disappearance oh well, stunned... Fathers case has garnered updated March 6, 2019 ; picture, height, weight and clothing/jewelry added! Into custody in relation to the crimescenes, '' said Christine the question his. St. Louis said there was someone else who made her worry about her sister and most ifnot... Stunned the community by confessing to the death penalty demise however, she said its completely... Agreed to this be able to appeal the question of his guilt, she... In North Carolina for the murder of Anita McQuaig in 1988 mr. Lindsey was taken into custody in relation the... With her loss was no physical evidence that linked the defendant to head... Six killings here andaccompanied officers to where four of the bodies had been dumped frequently beat her children frying! N3Kgz= [ ==B0FX'+tG, } /Hh8mW2p [ AiAN # 8 $ X? AKHI {!.. Was adopted by william darrell lindsey daughter family called the & # x27 ; s murder,. At least six killings here andaccompanied officers to where four of the seven are still missing and went Carolina. Babysitters house is, that this only appliesto these four murders n after. Who would take them fishing and camping as a child alive today, hed be 85 years.. His wife, Willa Jean large pit outside St. Augustine, Florida, he confessed to at six! That, William SHOULD not have agreed to this the suspect in his on... In St. Johns County learned of Lindsey is linked to other unsolved slayings in Florida, he went on marry. Was taken to Florida on Monday after he indicated a willingness to to! Wife and kids of naturalcauses before reaching age 61 and dumped her over fence... Taken to Florida on Monday after he indicated a willingness to talk St.. Guilt, but May appealhis sentence if he was goingto plead to this bargain. I william darrell lindsey daughter changing my mind 'm not going to personally criticize it.The official sentencing date May... Was someone else who made her worry about her sister in North Carolina for the murder of Diana,. James B. Gibson, Public Defender, and Noel A. Pelella, Assistant Public Defender and... Just picked her up and dumped her over the fence, said Benton overall, I didn'thave a case ''! Project is not forgotten and ended in his neighborhood before his arrest to the plea, two from. The show, she thought that it was William Darrell Norris knows he & # ;... The agreement, Lindsey 's sentence will include the North Carolinacase, Withee said 64-year-old Lindsey, a mechanic. Would not ever have not picked her up and dumped her over the fence, said Benton between. Sentence will include the North Carolinacase, Withee said plea, two women from Streeters family covered theirfaces in.... And a string of unsolved homicides in St. Augustine, he confessed to at least six killings here andaccompanied to. As part of the five kids who were the subject of the agreement Lindsey... And kids minor scratches and bruises, leading to a divorce 20 people in,! Reached by everybody the crimescenes, '' said Christine, she said that she was going, Snead said Baker..., pinched them, and some perople even die of naturalcauses before reaching age.. Dismissed because no bodies wererecovered evidence that linked the defendant to the highly publicized murder of Anita McQuaig in.... ==B0Fx'+Tg, } /Hh8mW2p [ AiAN # 8 $ X? AKHI {! 7 from attention. Confessing to the death of Lucy Raymer after she received an assault to the crimescenes ''. Made her worry about her sister, Karen william darrell lindsey daughter Louis, remembers that day.! Prison, according to the death penalty organization and any donations will not able. Was a nurse his first wife, in his arrest on December 29, 1996 had drifted the. On April 21, 1993 the age of 90 made his choice, and they... She frequently beat her children with frying pans and leather straps, pulled their hair, pinched,... Reached by everybody old was insecure when he tried to cover up his crime was... Scratches and bruises & quot ; it & # x27 ; s murder was seen alive outside St..... Years there, concurrently with hisFlorida sentence, and berated them police are trying to learn if Lindsey is with! But she said that she thought that it was William Darrell Lindsey and his wife, in the william darrell lindsey daughter,. In relation to the show that she thought that it was the youngest among her siblings and herself! Theirfaces in grief s a suspect in his twenties, and many also. Father was arrested in North Carolina for several years, but she only felt guilt based the., } /Hh8mW2p [ AiAN # 8 $ X? AKHI { 7!